Skip to content

How we rate charities

The Clarity Score V1.1 adds up to 100 points from UK regulator filings — statutory inquiry sets the score to zero.

Scores are never for sale — see how we're funded and the commercial independence clause below.

Four beacons

Assessed

Accountability & Transparency

40 points — filing history (15), trustee oversight (15, scaling up to a board of three or more), declared policies (10).

Assessed

Financial Health

30 points — reserves (15, full marks 3–24 months, tapering on both sides), income stability (10), liabilities to assets (5, scaling down as debt rises).

Assessed

Financial Efficiency

20 points — program expense ratio and fundraising cost, each on a graduated scale (not a single cutoff). Kept at 20% of the total: financial-ratio scoring alone is not a reliable effectiveness signal (see "why not just an overhead ratio?" below).

Assessed

Community Support

10 points — volunteer-to-staff ratio from Charity Commission workforce data, scaling continuously up to a 2:1 ratio.

Score to stars

Score Stars Label
90+ ★★★★★ Exceptional
75+ ★★★★☆ Good
60+ ★★★☆☆ Needs improvement
1+ ★★☆☆☆ Poor
0+ ☆☆☆☆☆ Not rated

What we measure today

  • Accountability & Transparency (40 pts): five-year filing history, trustee oversight (scaling up to a board of three or more, the minimum recommended by the Charity Governance Code), safeguarding / conflict / volunteer policies.
  • Financial Health (30 pts): reserves (full marks 3–24 months, tapering on both sides), three-year income trend, liabilities-to-assets.
  • Financial Efficiency (20 pts): program expense ratio and fundraising cost per £1 raised, each on a graduated scale rather than a single pass/fail cutoff.
  • Community Support (10 pts): volunteer-to-staff ratio from regulator workforce data where disclosed (England & Wales annual-return fields; OSCR and CCNI records often omit this, so the beacon may be thinner).

Every filing figure traces back to the charity's own accounts, prepared under the Charity SORP accounting standard and submitted to the relevant UK regulator — the Charity Commission for England and Wales, OSCR in Scotland, or CCNI in Northern Ireland. Governance metrics reference the voluntary Charity Governance Code, which the Commission endorses but does not mandate. We don't score outcomes or real-world impact — public filings don't capture that, so we don't claim to measure it.

Policies & red flags

Statutory inquiry (kill switch)

If the relevant UK regulator has an open statutory inquiry, the charity scores 0/100 automatically with a regulatory warning banner — no pillar math is applied.

Red flags

Factual cards — statutory inquiry, fewer than three trustees, late filings, high fundraising spend, sharp income drops, very high reserves.

Give with Confidence

Score 75+ (about 4★ on the 5-star display), no serious red flags, filings up to date, no statutory inquiry.

What we exclude from a full score

A full Clarity Score needs detailed annual-return fields. Charities under £100,000 income, and many OSCR/CCNI records with thinner published returns, get a basic register profile instead of a score. Optional donor support never influences ratings. Basic profiles cover charities in our latest extracts from the three UK regulators; recent registrations may not appear until the next refresh.

Financial peer comparisons

These comparisons provide context alongside the Clarity Score and do not change it. We group active charities in our detailed dataset by regulator, primary cause category, latest annual income band and year in which the accounts end. Records with registration notices and the fictional demo are excluded. The cause category is a broad directory classification, not proof of an identical delivery model.

  • We require known start and end dates covering 350–378 days (50–54 weeks). Short first accounts, extended periods and unknown period lengths are excluded. We do not annualise them or mix them with full years.
  • The featured charity is excluded from its peers. A panel appears only when at least ten other charities qualify. Each measure needs ten disclosed peer values before we publish its median.
  • Income and expenditure come from the same latest period. Charitable activities share divides the disclosed charitable expenditure by total expenditure for that period, using our existing disclosure checks. Missing or invalid values are excluded; reported zeros remain zeros.
  • The median is the middle sorted value, or the mean of the middle two values. Coverage beside each median shows how many qualifying peers supply that measure. It is a dataset comparison, not a census of every UK charity.

Year-end months, service costs, restricted grants, accounting policies and grant-making versus direct delivery can still differ. A higher spending share or larger income is not evidence of greater effectiveness. We do not benchmark reserves here: readily comparable unrestricted reserve figures are not available across the cohort. See how to choose between similar charities.

Cost to raise £1 of donations

Profiles and comparisons show how much a charity spent on raising funds for each £1 it received in donations and legacies. It sits beside the Clarity Score. It is not part of the score and does not change any weight.

  • Inputs come from the same accounts period of the charity's Charity Commission annual return (Part B): income from donations and legacies, expenditure on raising funds, investment management costs and income from other trading activities.
  • Figure = (expenditure on raising funds − investment management costs) ÷ income from donations and legacies. Under the Charities SORP, investment management costs are part of raising-funds spend; we take them out because they relate to investment income, not donations. Figures below £1 are shown in pence, rounded to the nearest penny.
  • Each accounts year is calculated on its own. When at least two of the three most recent accounts years have a figure, we also show a combined figure: total raising-funds spend ÷ total donations and legacies across those years. It is weighted by size, not an average of the yearly figures.
  • Missing is kept apart from zero. A blank value on the return gives no figure (“not reported”). Donations and legacies of zero leave nothing to divide by (“no donations”). Raising-funds spend of zero is shown as a real 0p.
  • We don't show a figure for a year in which trading income is 10% or more of donations and legacies (see trading income below).

Caveats

  • Only larger filers report the split. Charities complete Part B of the annual return only for years with income over £500,000, so smaller charities, and smaller years of larger ones, have no figure. Scottish (OSCR) and Northern Irish (CCNI) records are not covered.
  • Legacies are lumpy. One large gift in a will can halve the figure one year and double it the next. Read the yearly table and the combined figure rather than a single year.
  • Trading income is excluded. Shop sales and other trading are not donations, so they are not in the denominator. But the SORP puts trading costs, such as running shops, inside raising-funds spend, and the register does not separate them. That is why we withhold the figure when trading is 10% or more of donations. Below that level some trading costs may remain, so profiles show the trading income beside the figure.
  • Raising-funds spend can cover other income. Charities allocate shared costs differently, and some put costs linked to other income under raising funds. A figure of £1 or more should be checked against the accounts. Others record fundraising costs under other headings, so 0p does not always mean fundraising cost nothing.
  • It is not an impact or quality measure. A low figure does not mean a charity does good work. A charity building a new supporter base or investing in legacy marketing can show a higher figure for sound reasons, and grant-making intermediaries that pass donations on often show close to 0p.
  • It differs from the scored fundraising metric. The Clarity Score's fundraising efficiency divides fundraising cost by total income. This figure divides by donations and legacies only, and it is not scored.

Commercial independence

CharityCompare sells memberships and advertising. These relationships are administered by a separate commercial process from the scoring pipeline, which runs entirely on UK regulator filings. Scores are regenerated from filings on a fixed schedule; no staff member can adjust an individual score. Paid placements are labelled “Featured partner” and are excluded from all ranked lists, leaderboards and comparison tools. If a charity cancels a paid plan, its score does not change — because it was never connected.

A worked Clarity Score example

This is a fictional calculation, generated by the same formula as our real ratings. It is not a charity, review or donation recommendation.

Example inputs

Three years each with £1 million income, £800,000 expenditure, £640,000 charitable-activities spending and £80,000 fundraising costs. Three trustees; all three assessed policies disclosed; no late filings or statutory inquiry. Reserves £400,000, assets £600,000, liabilities £60,000, 10 staff and 20 volunteers.

Programme-spending share: £640,000 ÷ £800,000 = 80%. Fundraising cost relative to all income: £80,000 ÷ £1 million = 8p per £1. This is not a cost per £1 of donations because the denominator includes other income.

Calculated score: 92/100

Accountability & Transparency: 40/40 points
  • Filing history (5 years): 15/15

    15/15 pts

    No recorded lateness in available history = 15 pts · one late filing = 5 pts · two or more or unknown status = 0 pts. Missing data is not proof of late filing.

  • Trustee oversight: 15/15

    3 trustees · 15/15 pts

    Three or more trustees on the register = 15 pts, scaled down for fewer (governance red flag below three).

  • Declared policies: 10/10

    10/10 pts

    Safeguarding (4) · conflict of interest (3) · volunteer management (3) — from Charity Commission annual return.

Financial Health: 24/30 points
  • Reserves (months of expenditure): 15/15

    6 months · 15/15 pts

    3–24 months = full marks, tapering on both sides · 0 months or 4+ years = 0 pts. Reserves are not necessarily cash; needs vary by operating model.

  • Income stability / growth: 5/10

    5/10 pts · 3-year average

    +20% or more over the window = 10 pts · flat = 5 pts · −20% or worse = 0 pts, scaled between.

  • Liabilities to assets: 4/5

    10% · 4/5 pts

    0% liabilities-to-assets = 5 pts, scaling down to 0 pts at 60%+ debt.

Financial Efficiency: 18/20 points
  • Program expense ratio: 8/10

    80% · 8/10 pts (3-year average)

    90%+ on charitable activities = full marks, scaling down to 0 pts at 50% or below.

  • Fundraising efficiency: 10/10

    8p per £1 income · 10/10 pts (3-year average, disclosed years)

    ≤10p to raise £1 = full marks, scaling down to 0 pts at 40p or above (fundraising cost ÷ income).

Community Support: 10/10 points
  • Volunteer-to-staff ratio: 10/10

    20 volunteers / 10 staff · 10/10 pts

    Volunteers at 2x staff or more = full marks · no volunteers = 0 pts, scaled between.

What happens when fields are missing?

Keeping the same financial years but omitting governance, workforce, assets and reserves inputs gives 23/100 under V1.1. Several undisclosed inputs earn zero points. V1.1 does not reweight the total to compensate. Unknown filing status earns no filing points. These are limitations of the formula, not findings that a charity lacks policies, is poorly governed or has no volunteers. Compare disclosure coverage as well as scores.

Our formula uses published proxies and chosen thresholds. It cannot establish programme effectiveness, fraud risk, service quality or the best use of your donation. A statutory inquiry triggers V1.1’s zero-score rule; an inquiry is not itself a finding of wrongdoing. Historical or exceptional register records are excluded from current promotional rankings.

V1.1 excludes missing fundraising-cost fields from the scoring average. An explicit reported zero is retained; no disclosed costs means no fundraising points. A fourfold income discontinuity, a gap in annual periods or an unusually short/long period receives no trend points pending comparability review. These rules make missingness and reporting boundaries visible, but do not turn financial ratios into impact evaluations.

See disclosure coverage in the refreshed dataset. Independent external assessment of the scoring design remains pending.

Methodology changelog · Scoring guide

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Sources: Charity Commission for England and Wales, Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator and Charity Commission for Northern Ireland. Open Government Licence v3.0 .

Common questions

What is the Clarity Score?

The Clarity Score is CharityCompare’s proprietary 0–100 rating from UK regulator annual returns. Higher scores indicate stronger accountability, finance, and transparency signals from public filings — not programme impact.

Which pillars does the Clarity Score use?

Four pillars: Accountability & Transparency (40 pts), Financial Health (30 pts), Financial Efficiency (20 pts), and Community Support (10 pts). Display stars use the same bands: 90+ is 5★ Exceptional, 75+ is 4★ Good, 60+ is 3★ Needs improvement, 1–59 is 2★ Poor. A statutory inquiry automatically scores 0/100.

Where does CharityCompare get its data?

The three UK charity registers: the Charity Commission for England and Wales, OSCR in Scotland, and the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland. We do not use self-reported marketing claims or paid submissions. A full Clarity Score needs detailed annual-return fields; thinner records get a basic profile instead of a guessed score.

Is CharityCompare affiliated with the Charity Commission?

No. CharityCompare is an independent service, not part of or endorsed by the Charity Commission for England and Wales. We reuse the Commission’s public register data under the Open Government Licence v3.0 and present it in our own format — the Clarity Score is our own algorithmic summary, not an official rating. Always verify a charity directly on the official register at register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk.

Why not just score charities on their overhead / fundraising cost ratio?

In 2013 the BBB Wise Giving Alliance, GuideStar and Charity Navigator jointly renounced the "overhead ratio" as a stand-alone measure of a charity's quality (the "Overhead Myth"): a low ratio doesn't reliably predict effectiveness, and chasing one can push charities to under-invest in the infrastructure they need. We still use program-expense and fundraising-cost ratios — UK regulator filings don't give us outcomes data to weigh instead — but keep that pillar the smallest (20 of 100 points) and score it on a graduated scale rather than a single cutoff, alongside governance and financial-health pillars.

What is the cost to raise £1 of donations?

For each accounts year, it is a charity's expenditure on raising funds, less investment management costs, divided by its income from donations and legacies, from Part B of its Charity Commission annual return. Only years with income over £500,000 have that split. We withhold it when trading income is 10% or more of donations, because raising-funds spend then includes shop and other trading costs. Legacies make it lumpy, and it is not part of the Clarity Score or a measure of impact.