Skip to content
THE SAVE THE CHILDREN FUND

80/100 4★

Reg. 213890

compared with
ISLAMIC RELIEF WORLDWIDE

93/100 5★

Reg. 328158

Large aid agency vs specialist charity

In short: The large agency in this example centres on children’s welfare and relief across countries. The specialist example pairs emergency relief with long-term development in education, livelihoods, health and water. Choose by the work you want to fund.

Last reviewed by CharityCompare editorial.

Whichever you choose, first confirm which registered entity receives your gift and which appeal it supports, because both examples sit within wider groups of related organisations. Compare results with the relevant population and reporting period, and remember that emergency outputs and longer-term outcomes need different measures. Neither profile has a source-checked programme result, which is a gap in our coverage rather than evidence either way.

Large aid agency vs specialist charity: key differences

What to compare THE SAVE THE CHILDREN FUND ISLAMIC RELIEF WORLDWIDE
Registered work and operating model Children’s welfare and relief across countries. Emergency relief and long-term development.
What to consider Its purposes cover children’s welfare internationally. Compare country and programme results with the relevant population and reporting period, and distinguish this UK registration from other members of the wider movement. The register describes emergency response alongside education, livelihoods, health and water. Emergency outputs and longer-term outcomes require different measures. Do not combine results from affiliated organisations without checking reporting boundaries.
Access and practical checks Check the named appeal and delivery organisation. A donation restriction or country programme should be confirmed on the official appeal page. Confirm which registered entity receives the donation and which appeal it supports. Ask about any restrictions attached to a designated donation.
Sourced result or evidence gap No programme outcome has been source-checked for this profile. This is a gap in our coverage, not evidence of no impact. No programme outcome has been source-checked for this profile. This is a gap in our coverage, not evidence of no impact.

What the latest filings show

Figures from the accounts held in our dated dataset; the live register may contain newer filings. Ratios can span multiple years, as labelled. Clarity scores use our methodology. Cost to raise £1 of donations is not part of the score; legacies make it lumpy, and it is withheld where trading costs would distort it (how it works).

These snapshots have different latest accounts years. Compare the same period in the full profiles before drawing a conclusion from a financial difference.

Metric THE SAVE THE CHILDREN FUND ISLAMIC RELIEF WORLDWIDE
Latest accounts year in our snapshot 2025 2024
Financial snapshot refreshed 2026-09-06 2026-09-06
Ratio reporting window 3-yr avg 3-yr avg
Overall score 80/100 (4★) 93/100 (5★)
Accountability & Finance 100/100 100/100
Spend on charitable activities 86% of expenditure 91% of expenditure
Fundraising efficiency £7.4 total income per £1 fundraising (2023–2025, disclosed years) £14.9 total income per £1 fundraising (2022–2024, disclosed years)
Cost to raise £1 of donations Not shown for 2025: trading income was 13% of donations 8p per £1 (2024) · 7p over 2022–2024
Latest income £263m £276m
Fundraising spend 13% of expenditure 7% of expenditure
Reserves 2 months 2 months
Accounts filing On time On time
Data confidence high high
Charity number 213890 328158

THE SAVE THE CHILDREN FUND on the register · ISLAMIC RELIEF WORLDWIDE on the register

Considering Large international aid agency

  • Children’s welfare and relief across countries.
  • Check the named appeal and delivery organisation. A donation restriction or country programme should be confirmed on the official appeal page.
Full profile →

Considering Specialist niche charity

  • Emergency relief and long-term development.
  • Confirm which registered entity receives the donation and which appeal it supports. Ask about any restrictions attached to a designated donation.
Full profile →

Large aid agency vs specialist charity: questions answered

Large international aid agency or Specialist niche charity: which should I support?

There is no universal winner. Children’s welfare and relief across countries. Emergency relief and long-term development. Check the programme that interests you, the accounts period and the evidence behind any result. A financial rating is not an impact assessment.

Can I compare the headline results directly?

Only if the definitions, population, geography and reporting periods match. Research expenditure, service contacts and lasting outcomes measure different things. The source notes explain any figures included here.

How we score charities +

The Clarity Score is a 100-point rating from UK regulator filings (Charity Commission for England and Wales, OSCR and CCNI). Four pillars — Accountability & Transparency (40), Financial Health (30), Financial Efficiency (20), and Community Support (10) — each scored on a continuous scale, not pass/fail cutoffs. A statutory inquiry sets the score to 0 automatically.

Full methodology →

Accountability & Transparency

Scored from filings

40 points — filing history (15), trustee oversight (15, scaling up to a board of three or more), declared policies (10).

Financial Health

Scored from filings

30 points — reserves (15, full marks 3–24 months, tapering on both sides), income stability (10), liabilities to assets (5, scaling down as debt rises).

Financial Efficiency

Scored from filings

20 points — program expense ratio and fundraising cost, each on a graduated scale (not a single cutoff). Kept at 20% of the total: financial-ratio scoring alone is not a reliable effectiveness signal (see "why not just an overhead ratio?" below).

Community Support

Scored from filings

10 points — volunteer-to-staff ratio from Charity Commission workforce data, scaling continuously up to a 2:1 ratio.

Overall score

Sum of all pillar points. Display stars use the same bands as the labels: 90–100 → 5★ Exceptional; 75–89 → 4★ Good; 60–74 → 3★ Needs improvement; 1–59 → 2★ Poor; 0 → not rated.